Skip to main content

Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) vs Home Equity Loan

Updated

Your home equity — the difference between your home’s value and what you owe — can be a powerful financial tool. The two main ways to access it are a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) and a home equity loan. Here is how they compare.

HELOC vs home equity loan at a glance

FeatureHELOCHome Equity Loan
How you receive fundsRevolving credit (draw as needed)Lump sum
Interest rateVariable (prime + margin)Usually fixed
Minimum paymentInterest-onlyPrincipal + interest
Repayment flexibilityPay interest only or moreFixed monthly payments
Maximum borrowingUp to 65% of home valueUp to 80% LTV (combined)
ReusableYes (as you repay, credit becomes available)No (one-time borrowing)
Typical ratePrime + 0.50% to 1.00%Prime + 1.00% to 2.00% (or fixed)
Best forOngoing or unpredictable expensesOne-time, known expenses

How a HELOC works

A HELOC functions like a credit card secured by your home:

  1. Lender approves a credit limit based on your home equity
  2. You draw funds as needed via cheques, transfers, or a linked card
  3. You pay interest only on the amount borrowed (minimum payment is usually interest-only)
  4. As you repay, credit becomes available again (revolving)

HELOC limits in Canada

  • Maximum HELOC: 65% of home value
  • HELOC + mortgage combined: Cannot exceed 80% of home value

Example

DetailValue
Home value$700,000
Remaining mortgage$350,000
Maximum total borrowing (80%)$560,000
Available for HELOC$210,000
HELOC limit (65% cap)$210,000 (within cap)

How a home equity loan works

A home equity loan provides a one-time lump sum:

  1. Lender approves a loan amount based on your home equity
  2. You receive the full amount upfront
  3. Fixed monthly payments of principal and interest over a set term
  4. Once repaid, the loan is closed (no revolving access)

Example

DetailValue
Home equity loan$100,000
Interest rate6.50% (fixed)
Term10 years
Monthly payment$1,135
Total interest paid$36,200

When to use a HELOC

Home renovations (phased)

If your renovation is happening in stages, a HELOC lets you draw funds as needed instead of paying interest on the full amount from day one.

Emergency fund

Keep a HELOC available as a backup — you only pay interest if you use it.

Investment purposes (Smith Manoeuvre)

Borrowing to invest can make the interest tax-deductible. See our Smith Manoeuvre guide for details.

Variable or uncertain expenses

When you do not know exactly how much you will need, a HELOC provides flexibility.

When to use a home equity loan

Debt consolidation

A lump sum at a fixed rate is ideal for paying off multiple high-interest debts. You know exactly what your payment will be each month.

Major one-time purchase

If you know the exact amount (full kitchen renovation, car purchase, education), a home equity loan gives payment certainty.

Disciplined repayment

Fixed payments force you to pay down the principal. HELOC interest-only payments can trap you in perpetual debt.

Risks and considerations

HELOC risks

  • Interest-only trap — Making only minimum payments means you never pay down the balance
  • Variable rate — Payments increase when rates rise
  • Spending temptation — Easy access to large amounts of credit
  • Your home is collateral — Default means losing your home
  • HELOC readvanceable mortgages — Some combined products automatically increase your HELOC as your mortgage is paid down, keeping total debt high

Home equity loan risks

  • Interest from day one — You pay interest on the full amount immediately, even if you do not use it all right away
  • Less flexibility — Cannot re-borrow once repaid
  • Your home is collateral — Same risk as HELOC

Tax implications

Use of FundsInterest Tax Deductible?
Investing (stocks, ETFs, rental property)Yes
Business expensesYes
Home renovationsNo
Debt consolidationNo
Personal use (vacation, car)No

Only interest on funds used for income-producing purposes is tax deductible in Canada. This applies to both HELOCs and home equity loans.

HELOC vs home equity loan costs

$100,000 borrowed, 5-year comparison

MetricHELOC (prime + 0.50%)Home Equity Loan (6.50% fixed)
Assumed rate6.45% (variable)6.50% (fixed)
Monthly payment (interest only for HELOC)$538$1,135
Balance after 5 years$100,000 (no principal paid)$37,900
Total interest paid$32,250$36,200

The HELOC costs less in interest but the balance has not decreased. The home equity loan forces principal repayment.

Bottom line

Choose a HELOC for flexible, ongoing borrowing needs and if you are disciplined about repayment. Choose a home equity loan for one-time lump sums where you want fixed payments and guaranteed payoff.

For either option, remember that your home is the collateral. Borrow conservatively and have a clear repayment plan. Use our mortgage calculator to model payments at different rates and amounts.