Tax-free (no tax on distributions or capital gains)
RRSP
Tax-deferred (taxed as income on withdrawal)
Non-registered
Distributions are a mix: return of capital (tax-deferred), other income (fully taxed), capital gains (50% inclusion) — T3 slip breaks it down
FHSA
Tax-free
REITs are most tax-efficient when held inside registered accounts (TFSA or RRSP) because distributions include a significant “other income” component that is fully taxed in non-registered accounts.
How Much Income from REIT ETFs?
Investment
Yield (~4.5%)
Monthly Income
$10,000
$450/yr
$37.50
$25,000
$1,125/yr
$93.75
$50,000
$2,250/yr
$187.50
$100,000
$4,500/yr
$375.00
$250,000
$11,250/yr
$937.50
REITs vs direct rental property
Many Canadians default to direct rental property as their real estate investment. Here is how REITs and REIT ETFs compare:
Factor
REIT ETF (e.g., VRE)
Direct rental property
Capital required
$50+
$100,000+ (down payment)
Diversification
Across 15–25 properties/REITs
Single property
Liquidity
Instant (sell on TSX)
Months to sell
Management
None
Tenant management, repairs
Returns
6–10%/yr (yield + growth)
5–15%/yr (highly variable)
Leverage
None
Mortgage leverage
Tax efficiency
Hold in TFSA/RRSP
Rental income + capital gains
Barrier to entry
Any amount
High — credit, down payment
Direct rental property offers the potential for higher returns through mortgage leverage, but requires significant capital, time, and risk tolerance. REIT ETFs offer lower returns on average but are accessible at any amount and require no active management.
Tax treatment of REIT distributions
REIT distributions in a non-registered account consist of multiple components taxed differently:
Distribution type
Tax treatment
Other income (return of capital)
Deferred — reduces your ACB; taxed as capital gain when sold