In-trust accounts (also called informal trusts) are one of the most misunderstood investment vehicles in Canada. Parents and grandparents open them thinking they’re saving for a child’s future with full control — but the reality is that the child legally owns the assets and can demand everything at age 18. The tax treatment is also complicated: interest and dividends are attributed back to the contributor (taxed at your rate), while only capital gains are taxed in the child’s hands. For most families, an RESP with its 20% government grant is a far better option.
What Is an In-Trust Account?
Feature
Details
Also called
Informal trust, ITF account
Structure
Adult trustee holds assets for minor beneficiary
Documentation
No formal trust deed
Legal ownership
Belongs to the child
Control
Adult manages until majority
How In-Trust Accounts Work
Setup
Step
Action
1
Open account at brokerage/bank
2
Register as “[Adult name] in trust for [Child name]”
3
Provide adult’s SIN and child’s SIN
4
Adult manages investments
Typical Uses
Use Case
Suitability
Saving for child’s future
Limited
Holding inheritance
Better options exist
Gift from grandparents
Consider RESP first
General savings
RESP often better
The Major Problem: Loss of Control
This is the issue that surprises most parents. Once you put money into an in-trust account, it legally belongs to the child. When they turn 18 (or 19 in some provinces), they can walk into the bank and withdraw everything — and there is nothing you can do about it. If you’ve saved $50,000 for their education and they decide to buy a car instead, that’s their legal right. If maintaining control over the funds matters to you, a formal trust ($1,500–5,000 in legal fees) with specific distribution terms is the only solution.
Age
Control
0-17
Adult trustee manages
18 (or 19)
Child has legal right to all assets
You cannot
Legally prevent access
No restrictions
Child can spend on anything
Example Scenario
Situation
Outcome
You save $50,000 for child’s education
—
Child turns 18
Full legal ownership
Child wants to buy a car
Can withdraw everything
Your recourse
None (legally their money)
Tax Treatment
Attribution Rules
Income Type
Who Pays Tax
Interest income
Parent/contributor
Dividend income
Parent/contributor
Capital gains
Child
Income on reinvested income
Child
Example
Year
Income
Who Pays Tax
Year 1: $1,000 dividend
$1,000
Parent
Year 2: $1,000 dividend + $40 on reinvested
$1,000 parent, $40 child
Capital gain on sale
Full amount
Child
After Age 18
Change
Details
Attribution ends
Income taxed to child
Capital gains
Still taxed to child
All new income
Child’s income
Comparing Savings Options for Children
Feature
In-Trust
RESP
Formal Trust
Government grants
No
Yes (20%+)
No
Tax-sheltered growth
No
Yes
Possible
Control after 18
Child
For education
Trustee
Attribution rules
Yes
N/A
Depends
Setup cost
Free
Free
$1,500+
Flexibility of use
Any purpose
Education
Per trust terms
Why RESP Is Usually Better
RESP Advantages
Advantage
Details
CESG grant
20% on first $2,500/year
Tax-sheltered
Growth not taxed until withdrawal
No attribution
Not your income
EAP taxed to student
Low/no tax
Control
Must be used for education
RESP vs In-Trust Example
Factor
RESP
In-Trust
Contribution
$50,000
$50,000
Government grants
$7,200
$0
Total invested
$57,200
$50,000
Tax on growth
None until withdrawal
Attributed + complex
Control
For education
Child at 18
If child doesn’t go to school
Options exist
Child keeps it all
When In-Trust Might Make Sense
Limited Situations
Scenario
Why In-Trust Could Work
RESP already maxed
Additional savings
Non-education purpose
Can’t use RESP
Capital gains income
Taxed to child anyway
Small amounts
Simplicity
Child is trustworthy
Comfortable with age 18 access
Capital Gains Strategy
Approach
Details
Invest in growth stocks
No dividends
Hold long-term
Defer gains
Child sells after 18
Their income, low/no tax
Formal Trust Alternative
When to Consider
Situation
Action
Large amounts (>$50,000)
Consider formal trust
Want control past 18
Formal trust required
Complex family situation
Get legal advice
Inheritance planning
Testamentary trust
Formal Trust Features
Feature
Details
Trust document
Lawyer-drafted
Control
Specifies terms, ages
Cost
$1,500-5,000+ setup
Annual tax return
T3 required
Income splitting
Age 18+ children
Tax Reporting
Who Reports What
Income Type
SIN to Use
Report On
Interest/Dividends (attributed)
Child’s SIN on T3/T5, report on parent’s return
Parent’s T1
Capital gains
Child’s SIN
Child’s T1
Second-generation income
Child’s SIN
Child’s T1
Record Keeping
Document
Why
Source of funds
Prove contributions
Cost base tracking
For capital gains
Income attribution records
Tax reporting
T3/T5 slips
Annual
Risks and Concerns
Legal Risks
Risk
Impact
Child demands money at 18
Must comply
Relationship changes
Child may use differently than intended
Child’s creditors
Can access the funds
Child’s divorce
May be divided
Tax Risks
Risk
Impact
Incorrect reporting
CRA reassessment
Missing attribution
Penalties
Complex calculations
Easy to get wrong
Converting Existing In-Trust Account
Options at Age of Majority
Option
Details
Transfer to child’s account
Simplest
Child keeps in-trust
Account continues
Can’t take back
Assets belong to child
If Child Doesn’t Want Money
Situation
Reality
Child wants parent to keep managing
Can do informally
Legal ownership
Still child’s
Can gift back
But gift tax doesn’t exist in Canada
The Bottom Line
For children’s education savings, an RESP is almost always better — 20% government grants, tax-sheltered growth, and the money must be used for education. In-trust accounts only make sense after the RESP is maxed, for non-education purposes, or when investing in growth stocks for capital gains (which are taxed in the child’s hands at a lower rate). If you need control past age 18, use a formal trust.