New Brunswick operates a private, competitive car insurance market where you can shop freely for all your coverage. The province uses a direct compensation property damage (DCPD) system, meaning if another driver is at fault, your own insurer handles your vehicle repairs — simplifying the process compared to chasing the at-fault driver’s insurer. New Brunswick has some of the most affordable car insurance rates in Canada, making it one of the better provinces for drivers frustrated by Ontario or Alberta costs.
Under DCPD, when you are not at fault in a collision, your own insurer pays for your vehicle repairs (up to your coverage limits), then seeks reimbursement from the at-fault driver’s insurer. For you, this means faster service and dealing only with your own insurer — a significant convenience over the traditional tort process.
Average Costs in New Brunswick
By Driver Profile
Profile
Annual Cost
Experienced driver, clean record
$900–$1,200
Average driver
$1,000–$1,300
New driver (0–2 years)
$2,000–$3,000
Young driver (under 25)
$2,200–$3,500
Driver with at-fault claim
+30–60%
By City and Region
Location
Average Annual
Saint John
$1,100–$1,500
Moncton
$1,000–$1,400
Fredericton
$1,000–$1,300
Miramichi
$950–$1,250
Bathurst
$950–$1,250
Edmundston
$900–$1,200
Rural New Brunswick
$850–$1,200
Saint John has slightly higher rates than other NB cities, reflecting higher urban density and claims frequency. Fredericton and Moncton are comparable. Rural areas benefit from lower traffic volume and fewer accidents.
Mandatory Coverage
What New Brunswick Law Requires
Coverage
Minimum
Third-party liability
$200,000
Accident benefits
Statutory
Uninsured motorist
Required
Direct compensation (DCPD)
Required
Accident Benefits
New Brunswick’s statutory accident benefits provide basic compensation for injuries:
Benefit
Amount
Medical and rehabilitation
$50,000
Income replacement
80% of gross income, up to $250/week
Death benefit
$10,000
Funeral expenses
$2,500
For drivers without comprehensive disability coverage through work, enhanced accident benefits are worth considering.
Optional Coverage
Common Additions
Coverage
Purpose
Collision
Covers damage to your vehicle in a crash
Comprehensive
Theft, fire, hail, flooding, vandalism
All perils
Combined collision and comprehensive
Increased liability
Raise minimum above $200,000
Loss of use
Rental car during repairs
Accident forgiveness
Protect your record after first at-fault claim
Waiver of depreciation
New vehicle protection (within 2 years)
Increasing Liability
The $200,000 minimum is widely considered too low for meaningful protection.
Liability
Annual Cost to Add
$500,000
+$20–$40
$1,000,000
+$40–$70
$2,000,000
+$60–$100
How to Save on New Brunswick Car Insurance
Strategy
Savings
Compare 4–6 insurers
15–30%
Bundle home and auto
10–20%
Keep a clean driving record
20–50% long-term
Increase deductible
10–20%
Winter tires
Up to 5%
Anti-theft device
Up to 10% on comprehensive
Pay annually
2–5%
Driving school (young drivers)
10–15%
Low-mileage discount
5–10%
Brokers vs Direct
In New Brunswick, independent brokers access multiple insurers at once and are often the fastest route to competitive pricing. Direct writers (TD Insurance, Belair Direct) are worth checking too, but never limit yourself to a single quote.
Top Insurers in New Brunswick
Insurer
Notes
Intact Insurance
Market leader nationally
TD Insurance
Competitive multi-product discounts
Aviva Canada
Strong Atlantic presence
Co-operators
Cooperative model, good service
Wawanesa
Competitive in Atlantic Canada
Belair Direct
Lower overhead, competitive pricing
Economical (Definity)
Broker channel
Gore Mutual
Broker-distributed
New Brunswick vs Other Provinces
Province
Average Annual
Ontario
$1,900–$2,400
BC
$1,800–$2,400
Alberta
$1,400–$1,900
Nova Scotia
$1,100–$1,500
New Brunswick
$1,000–$1,300
PEI
$950–$1,300
Newfoundland
$900–$1,200
Quebec
$800–$1,300
New Brunswick is consistently among the most affordable private-market provinces for car insurance.
Filing a Claim in New Brunswick
Step
Action
1
Contact your insurer immediately
2
File police report if injuries, crime, or significant damage
3
Document the scene (photos, witness information)
4
Exchange insurance and contact information
5
Submit claim through your insurer’s app, phone, or online portal
6
Bring vehicle to approved repair facility
7
Pay deductible to the repair shop
If you disagree with a claim decision, you can contact the Financial and Consumer Services Commission of New Brunswick (FCNB) or use the General Insurance OmbudService (GIO) for dispute resolution.
Free chequing that earns interest on every dollar — no monthly fees, no minimums.
$25 BONUS
Open a free Wealthsimple chequing account
No monthly fees · Earns interest · Free e-Transfers