Skip to main content

Consumer Proposal vs Bankruptcy in Canada: Complete Insolvency Guide (2026)

Updated

When You Might Need Insolvency Help

Warning SignDetails
Can’t make minimum paymentsCash flow crisis
Using credit for essentialsFood, utilities on credit
Creditors threatening legal actionLawsuits, garnishment
Total debt exceeds annual income100%+ debt-to-income
No end in sightCan’t see paying off debt

Insolvency Options Overview

OptionDebt RepaidTimelineCredit ImpactBest For
Debt Management Plan100%3-5 yearsR7Lower debt, can afford payments
Consumer Proposal20-50%Up to 5 yearsR7Moderate debt, some income
BankruptcyLittle to none9-21+ monthsR9Overwhelming debt, limited income

Consumer Proposal

How It Works

StepWhat Happens
1. Consult LITFree consultation with Licensed Insolvency Trustee
2. Make an offerPropose to pay portion of debt
3. Creditors voteMust be accepted by majority
4. Make paymentsMonthly payments to LIT
5. CompleteAfter final payment, balance forgiven

Typical Terms

FactorDetails
Amount repaid20-50% of debt (varies)
Payment termUp to 60 months
AssetsKeep all assets
Interest0% during proposal

Example Consumer Proposal

DebtAmount
Credit cards$30,000
Personal loan$10,000
CRA debt$5,000
Total$45,000
ProposalDetails
Offer$18,000 (40%)
Monthly payment$300
Duration60 months
Savings$27,000

Eligibility

RequirementDetails
Debt amountLess than $250,000 (excluding mortgage)
Must have incomeTo make payments
Canadian residentOr property/business in Canada
Not a corporationMust be individual or sole proprietor

Bankruptcy

How It Works

StepWhat Happens
1. Meet with LITFree consultation
2. File bankruptcyLIT files paperwork
3. Surrender assetsNon-exempt assets
4. DutiesCounselling, surplus income
5. DischargeDebts eliminated

Timeline

TypeFirst-TimeSecond-Time
No surplus income9 months24 months
Surplus income21 months36 months

Surplus Income

Single PersonAmount
Threshold~$2,654/month (2024)
Over threshold50% of excess goes to estate

If you earn $3,654/month: ($3,654 - $2,654) × 50% = $500/month to bankruptcy estate.

Exempt Assets (Ontario Example)

AssetExempt Amount
Equity in home$10,783
Vehicle$7,117
Household goods$14,180
Tools of trade$14,405
RRSPs/RRIFsMostly exempt
PensionsExempt

Exemptions vary by province.

What Debts Are NOT Discharged

Debt TypeReason
Student loans (under 7 years)Must be 7+ years since end of studies
Child/spousal supportCourt-ordered, never discharged
Fines/penalties (court-ordered)Criminal fines, parking tickets
Fraud-related debtDishonesty in obtaining
Secured debtsMust relinquish collateral or reaffirm

Consumer Proposal vs Bankruptcy

FactorConsumer ProposalBankruptcy
Amount repaid20-50% typicallyUsually nothing
Keep assetsYesExempt assets only
DurationUp to 5 years9-21+ months
Surplus incomeN/AMay extend duration
Credit ratingR7R9
Credit report3 years after completion6-7 years after discharge
Public recordYesYes
Court involvementOnly if issuesMinimal

Finding a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT)

What to Look For

FactorWhy
Licensed by OSBLegally required
Free consultationStandard practice
Explains all optionsNot just pushing one solution
Clear feesNo hidden costs
Good reviewsCheck Google, trustee directories

Where to Find

ResourceDetails
OSB (Office of Superintendent of Bankruptcy)Official directory
Canadian Association of Insolvency ProfessionalsMember directory
Referral from credit counsellingOften have relationships

Credit Impact and Rebuilding

During Insolvency

ActionAllowed
Keep existing accountsUsually closed by creditors
Get new creditVery difficult
Secured credit cardPossible with deposit

After Completion

TimelineAction
ImmediatelyGet secured credit card
6-12 monthsApply for credit builder loan
1-2 yearsMay qualify for regular credit card
3-7 yearsInsolvency removed from credit report