Skip to main content

Why Did My Credit Score Drop? Common Reasons in Canada

Updated

A credit score drop feels alarming, but virtually every drop has a specific, identifiable cause visible on your credit report. In Canada, Equifax and TransUnion each maintain a separate score — they can differ by 10–30 points even with identical underlying data, and they use slightly different scoring models. When your score drops unexpectedly, the cause is almost always one of six things: a utilization spike, a hard inquiry, a missed payment, a credit limit reduction, a new account opening, or a credit report error. Identifying which one tells you both what happened and how long recovery will take. This article is part of the Canadian credit scores hub.

The most common cause by far — and the most misunderstood — is credit utilization. Your balance is reported to the bureaus on your statement closing date, not your payment due date. A large purchase made before your statement closes will show on your report as a high balance even if you pay the card in full the following week. This means your score can drop and recover within a single month without any actual financial problem. Knowing the timing of your statement close date is one of the most practical pieces of credit management knowledge available.


Score Impact by Cause

CauseTypical Score DropRecovery Time
Hard inquiry (new credit application)−5 to −10 points6–12 months (inquiry on file 3–6 years)
New credit account opened−5 to −20 points12–24 months (average account age recovers slowly)
Credit utilization exceeds 30%−20 to −50 points1–2 billing cycles once balance paid down
Credit utilization exceeds 75%−50 to −100 points1–2 billing cycles
Credit limit reduced by issuer−20 to −60 pointsWhen limit is restored or balance paid down
First missed payment (30+ days late)−50 to −100 points2–3 years on file; 6 years on report
Second missed paymentAdditional −30 to −60 points3–5 years
Collection account registered−50 to −150 points6 years from date of last activity
Consumer proposal filed−100 to −200 pointsEquifax: 3 yrs after completion; TransUnion: up to 6 yrs
Bankruptcy filed−150 to −240 pointsEquifax: 6 yrs after discharge; TransUnion: up to 7 yrs
Closing an old credit card−5 to −25 points6–24 months
Paying off an installment loan−5 to −15 points3–6 months

The Six Most Common Causes

1. Credit Utilization Spike

Credit utilization — your balance divided by your credit limit — is the second most heavily weighted factor in your score after payment history. The bureaus receive your balance as of your statement closing date, not your payment due date. A large expense charged before your statement closes will appear on your report as a high balance even if you pay it off in full the following week.

On a $5,000 credit card, a $2,200 charge before your statement closes reports 44% utilization. Your score drops 30–50 points. You pay it off the next week. Your score recovers the following month when the new statement closes at a lower balance. No lasting damage — but the timing caught you.

The fix for recurring large purchases is a mid-cycle payment before your statement closing date, not just before the payment due date. Paying before the statement closes means the balance reported to the bureaus reflects the lower amount. If your spending regularly approaches your limit, a proactive credit limit increase request is worth considering before the issuer acts first.

2. Hard Inquiry from a Credit Application

Every application for new credit — credit card, car loan, mortgage, line of credit, phone plan on contract — generates a hard inquiry. Each hard inquiry reduces your score by 5–10 points and remains visible on your report for 3–6 years, though it stops affecting your score meaningfully after 12 months.

Hard Inquiries in 12 MonthsApproximate Score Impact
1−5 to −10 points
2–3−10 to −20 points
4–6−20 to −40 points
7+Significant; signals credit-seeking behaviour to lenders

The exception to the per-inquiry rule is rate shopping: multiple mortgage or auto loan inquiries within 14–45 days are typically treated as a single inquiry by most scoring models, on the assumption that you are comparing rates for one purchase rather than seeking multiple new credit products. This grouping does not apply to credit card applications. See how long a hard inquiry stays on your credit for the full timeline.

3. Missed or Late Payment

A missed payment is the largest single-event score drop for most Canadians. Lenders typically report to the bureau after a payment is 30 days past due — meaning you usually have a short window after the due date to pay before it appears on your file. Once reported, it stays for 6 years.

Starting ScoreImpact of One Missed Payment
800+−100 to −140 points
750−90 to −110 points
700−60 to −80 points
650−50 to −70 points
600−30 to −50 points

The higher your score, the more you lose — because the scoring model penalizes the departure from your established pattern more severely. A borrower who has never missed a payment in ten years loses far more from a single miss than a borrower who has had previous lates.

4. Credit Limit Reduction by Your Issuer

If your lender reduces your credit card limit — which can happen during periodic account reviews, periods of economic stress, or prolonged card inactivity — your utilization ratio rises immediately even though your balance has not changed. On a $10,000 limit with a $2,500 balance (25% utilization), a reduction to $4,000 pushes utilization to 62.5%. A score drop of 30–60 points is common. See the credit limit decrease guide for how to appeal a reduction and prevent future ones.

5. New Account Reducing Average Account Age

When you open a new credit account, your average account age drops — a factor that scoring models weight positively for longer-established credit files. Three accounts aged 10, 7, and 5 years average 7.3 years. Opening a new account brings that average to 5.5 years. The score drop is typically 5–20 points and fades as the new account ages. This is not a reason to avoid opening accounts when you need them — the long-term credit mix benefit usually outweighs the temporary age reduction.

6. A Credit Report Error

Credit report errors are more common than most Canadians expect. Common examples include: accounts belonging to someone with a similar name appearing on your file; a paid collection still showing as outstanding; a closed account reported as open with a balance; duplicate accounts listed twice; or incorrect payment history on a legitimate account. If your score dropped and you cannot identify a specific action that caused it, pull your full report — not just the score — from both Equifax (equifax.ca) and TransUnion (transunion.ca). Bureaus are required to investigate disputes within 30 days under PIPEDA. The credit report dispute guide covers the process step by step.


How to Find the Cause

StepWhat to Look For
1. Pull both full reportsequifax.ca and transunion.ca — the full report, not just the score
2. Check your account listDid any new accounts appear that you did not open?
3. Check payment historyIs any account marked late that should not be?
4. Check balances and limitsDid any limit decrease? Did any balance report higher than expected?
5. Check the inquiries sectionWere any hard inquiries added you do not recognize?
6. Compare to last monthWhat specifically changed between your last score and now?

An unauthorized hard inquiry or account you did not open is a potential fraud signal. Contact the lender listed on the inquiry and both bureaus immediately. Place a fraud alert on your file, which requires lenders to take additional verification steps before approving new credit in your name.